Looking for fresh, fast pizza and Italian food options in Put-in-Bay? The locals know to find it at Cameo Pizza! Here, you’ll find fresh ingredients and fast service. Cameo Pizza makes their own sauce and crusts fresh daily. In addition to their standout pizza, you’ll find delicious subs, wraps, salads, and more!

Cameo Pizza is located on Catawba Avenue in downtown Put-in-Bay. Find them on the porch of the Grand Islander Hotel and across the street from the Put-in-Bay Brewing Company. It’s a short walk to the Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum.

Cameo Pizza History

Cameo Pizza’s tradition of excellence began in 1936. It was then that Mama Lococco served friends and family from her Monroe Street home in Sandusky, Ohio. Her Old World Italian Style and tasty offerings didn’t stay secret for long. Soon, word spread about her authentic, fresh food.

From these homey beginnings, Cameo Pizza grew. As a family owned and operated business, they are known for exceptional customer service, strong family values, and fresh delicious food. The care and quality are evident in each pizza and authentic Mama Lococco recipe.

Cameo Pizza Favorites

Choose from a full menu of fresh, fast, and tasty options.

Try these Cameo Pizza favorites: Chicken Ranch Zesty Mex (Taco) Vegetarian Popeye Special BLT All Meat Special

If you’re looking for something a little lighter consider a mouth-watering salads with garden greens, meats, cheeses, fruits, nuts, and a variety of dressings. They also offer a selection of crowd-pleasing appetizers, such as chicken bites and spicy wings.

Stop by at Cameo Pizza during their daily open hours from 11:30am-3:30 am. Staying in? Then call for local delivery! Perfect for late night cravings, Cameo Pizza offers delivery until 3 am.
Swing by or call today for the best pizza in Put-in-Bay!