Put-in-Bay Island Club #97 Su-Th $175-$325/nt, Fr-Sa $275-$1100/nt

"We have stayed in multiple Island Club rentals and have never been disappointed. Each one seems to be just a little bit different but all have been very nice, clean and well taken care of."

"Was very happy with our stay. We will be back again!"

"Perfect accommodations "

"Had a fantastic time! Split our crew with two rentals worked out perfectly. "

"Great time!"

"But this year was for our son’s 21st birthday getaway and we have an amazing time every year, the weather was perfect and there were no mayflies! "

"Was a great time for a bacholer party and the host had the place looking great. Would recommend booking this property. "

"The only sad thing was the outside light to the door we needed to go in was broken and couldn't be fixed for us, we had to use our phone flashlight to see the keypad. The rest of the stay was wonderful!"

"I recently had the pleasure of staying at Island Club Rentals in Put-in-Bay, and I must say it was a truly memorable experience for my family. From the moment we arrived until the time we left, we were impressed by the family-friendly atmosphere, the delightful amenities, and the exceptional service provided by the staff.

One of the highlights of our stay was the fantastic pool area. The pool was clean, well-maintained, and the perfect place for our family to relax and have fun. Whether we were lounging poolside or taking a refreshing swim, we always felt comfortable and enjoyed every moment spent in the water. The pool area also had ample seating and shade, making it a great spot for parents to unwind while keeping an eye on their little ones.

Speaking of cleanliness, the house we stayed in was immaculate. It was evident that the management takes great pride in maintaining their accommodations to a high standard. The rooms were spotless, and the furnishings were tasteful and comfortable. The kitchen was fully equipped with everything we needed to prepare meals, and the living area provided a cozy space for family bonding and relaxation.

What truly set Island Club Rentals apart was the exceptional staff. They were always available to assist us with any questions or concerns we had, and their friendly and welcoming demeanor made us feel right at home. Whether it was recommending local attractions or ensuring that we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay, the staff went above and beyond to make our visit memorable."

"#97 was very clean and tidy with wonderful decorative touches. Two full bathrooms allow for a family or group to stay in comfort. The back porch and table were nice to sit out and enjoy the May weather. Thank you to Island Club for a great stay! Order the golf cart, they'll bring it right to your house! "

"Great end of season getaway. Island was beautiful. Not as crowded, still plenty to see and enjoy. Can't wait to return"

"Overall decent."

"This was our first time in Put-in-Bay, but won't be our last! My family and I had an amazing time!"

"Very fun community to stay in had a great time with a bunch of like-minded people fun little pool overall the house had everything we needed. Would definitely stay again!"

"The cabin was perfect for what we needed. Beds were comfy and tvs in every room."

"This rental unit was fine and I would rent it again. It is a very comfortable house to rent. "

"Fun."

"A friend and I decided we were sick of working from our houses and wanted a change of scenery. Since we both live in the Cleveland area, we knew PIB would be a great local getaway that could provide us with some after-work fun! The condo we rented was super cute and the wifi worked perfectly! They had a great layout for us to set up our computers, work throughout the day (with the occasional margarita lunch ;)), and then go enjoy the nightlife! The cottage itself was peaceful and idyllic for those looking for a change of pace without spending an exorbitant amount of money. Great value, would highly recommend! If working from the condo, I highly recommend setting up shop on the back picnic table! "

"My boyfriend & I are so happy we booked Island Club #97! The communication and hospitality from the owner was top notch, and the golf cart rental was a breeze. The house was cozy and the utensil drawer saved the day after realizing we forgot our wine bottle opener! Although it was no longer peak-season, there was still a ton to do! We went out to several restaurants and bars, did some putt-putting, and enjoyed the scenery. On our next trip, we definitely plan on using Island Club 97 again!"

"Making plans for next year ! Was an awesome mother and daughters get away! Everything good location. Nice stay at Island club rentals! "

"My family and I had a great time, next time we come we will stay longer.
My grandkids are still talking about this trip and can't wait until next time."

"Awesome time at the Island club rental ,good location , nice and quiet area and friendly neighbors , Can’t wait to come back next year!"

"We had a wonderful stay at Island Club #97. It was nice to get away for a few days and enjoy the island with friends. We stayed at the house for the most part but were able to venture out and enjoy some sights that the Island Club staff recommended. The house was clean and nicely decorated which made our stay that much better. Our golf cart was ready when we arrived which was also a nice touch. I cannot wait to go back during the summer next year when the pool is open. Thank you!"

"We loved House #97! It is located in a quiet section of the Island Club and was the perfect destination for our group. It has been newly updated and redecorated. The house was clean and large enough for our group of 10. We will definitely be back next year! "

"House 27 Review:
We had a blast in #27! The house was recently redone and the decor is beautiful. The house was very clean and the staff was so accommodating. We loved being close to the pool! Can't wait to stay again next year!

House 97 Review:
House #97 was perfect for our stay! It was large enough to fit our entire group. The staff was amazing throughout our stay! The house was clean and recently updated. We will definitely request this house again in the future! "

"We made a quick trip to house #97 since the weather was so nice. We couldn't have been happier with our stay! The house was clean and updated. We loved the quiet location of this house! The staff was friendly and great throughout our stay. We will be back and will request #97!"

"It was great! When we got there, the staff said that the guests before us trashed the home and they were working to making the house up to standards and it was! They gave us new toilet seats, mattress covers, etc and it made us feel assured that they weren't going to let us stay in a trashed home which my entire group appreciated to the fullest extent. "

"This was the perfect location. We met a bunch of our neighbors which made the weekend even more fun. it's close to downtown! 10/10 recommend."

"I brought 18 guys to Put in Bay that had never even heard of it. We had the most amazing time and loved staying at the island club. Perfect setting for my little brothers bachelor party. The weekend was a huge success. "

"We had a great time this is a great location very clean"

"Great Rental"

"This rental spot was perfect for our annual friends trip to PIB. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Anytime you go to PIB this is the place to be!! "

"Great Time"

"Relaxing 3 day getaway to recharge and enjoy friends."

"Place was relatively clean and big enough for 10 people. Not the nicest place I've stayed at but it got the job done. No major complaints. They did replace empty propane tank quickly when we called."

"Had a great time. Property had everything we needed and was very quiet and peaceful. We had three teenage girls with us and also felt very safe at the property which was a priority. Pool was clean and well maintained. This is 2nd time we've stayed in the cabins and would definitely do it again."

"This is our at least 20 years of visiting Put in Bay, and we always stay at The Island Club. They treat us well and we love to have a house rather than a hotel room. We love it !! Everyone with the Island Club treats us well. We will be back next year.
"

"Fun "

"Awesome trip, great house/location. Would definitely recommend. "

"Nice "

"It was a great time as always. Island club is my favorite place to stay when I come to put in Bay!!!
"

"It was great! "

"Taking folks with disabilities to enjoy some fun with their peers is always more fun on an island! It's always made nicer by staying with Island Club folks!"

"Great time. Enough room for my family to stay "

"The property has a lovely deck on the back, which is private and scenic. This was a family stay, with a five year child, so the quiet during the week was appreciated. The kitchen has a good supply of dishes and a coffee maker. The pool is very small and crowded. There was a large soaking tub, which the child wanted to bathe in, but couldn't because none of the bathtubs had drain stoppers. Overall, it was an adequate summer cottage experience."

"We all had a great time. Cabin was clean and very comfortable. I only wish the owner had two things that would have helped a bit. #1) A dish strainer to put dishes in after washed.#2) a colander for draining washed veggies, pasta, shrimp. Other than that all else was very accommodating. The May fly's were a bit much but that can not be helped. LOL. "

"We stayed for my sisters bachelorette party! Everything. Was awesome the location, the pool and the taxi drivers. Coconut pomps was our favorite and always picked us up so quickly! I highly recommend this property and will most def be back!! "

"Place came fully furnished even down to the cooking utensils! Our grill ran out of propane after first use but other than that great experience beds were nice as well! "

"Weather was not good, so fishing was not the best.But we had a great time!It was nice to get away.The cabin was good.We appreciated the new washer/ dryer.There was not a vacuum in the cabin this year, so we cleaned up as best as we could.Did some sightseeing in the island.Can't wait to see you again next year!"

"Great time had by all and ease of dealing with all the Island Club ppl.was fantastic. 3rd. Year under our belt with anticipation of our 4th.!"

"Once again, I had an amazing experience staying at The Island Club. Upon arrival, we found we did not have a couple of necessary items in the kitchen (things one would expect to be there). My guests were totally surprised to see how quickly our needs were addressed and how pleasant the employee was. Sandy, the employee, was able to provide us with answers to any questions we had and also gave us advice. In addition, she told us about the new Island Club Condos where we are thinking about staying next year with a larger group!"

"very good experience except we were supposed to leave the rental clean (which is not a problem) but didnt have the items to clean the rental and staff didnt seem as friendly when we called to get the items. We still had a good time and would go back if/when another event arises. "

"The property owner was so accommodating and kind, it set the stage for an unbelievable family vacay. When we arrived, we soon found that the pics online scarcely did it justice. The home was clean and well maintained. It was spacious and accommodating for our family of 7. We hardly wanted to leave and explore the island. We also rented two golf carts, which were ready for us upon our check in. There was a very small mix up with us receiving an extra cart, however the matter was quickly and pleasantly resolved. The property owners make you feel welcome. Our family all agreed that this will be the first of many annual visits to this rents community and island. We cannot wait until next year!!"

"I booked this unit for a family gathering, not many units can accommodate 10 people so that worked very well. It is a nice unit close to the pool and the downtown area in Put-in-Bay. The inside was fairly clean but the outside could have used some cleaning. Be it the spider webs on the doors and railing or the pizza box and corn cobs that were left on the lawn. "

"We all enjoyed it! We had good fun, good food, and good relaxing!!"

"It took 3 phone calls and 3 hours after the 4pm check in to get the keys to the golf cart key dropped off. Overall, this place just needs general light maintenance, which you'd think they'd take care of over the winter. The pics on the website are from when this cabin was new. Alot of the wall pictures had fallen off. The sticky stuff and marks were on the walls though. A window in one bedroom was boarded up. The roll up shades were mostly on the floor of the bedrooms. One of the patio doors didn't lock, they had wood boards in the tracks to secure them. The deadbolt on the front door didn't work. so anyone really could've come in with the code. The smoke detector was hanging off the wall. Many lights didn't have bulbs. The back deck was unusable due to bird droppings and there was no hose to wash it off.The air conditioning vents need to be cleaned and the cobwebs in all the corners also. Other than all this minor stuff, the location was nice, the beds were comfortable, the showers worked and it was adequate for our needs.When most of the traffic left the island Sunday evening, the island was so much less congested and we enjoyed our stay."

"Everything was great super easy, everyone had a blast, neighbors were a blast! Close and easy to get around. Our water heater was not working that was the only bad thing, but everything else was great. "

"Nice house. Mirror fell off the wall in garden tub area. Nobody was in the room. Difficult to clean up without a vaccuum. "

"This place was nice enough and appropriate to stay at with a bunch of girls for a bachelorette party, as we did. Most of the cabins were full of groups partying and it was a lot of fun. I definitely would not go with a family on the weekend. You could during the week, but the cabins are pretty run down from so much partying that it's not really a nice, clean stay. It was awesome for a party scene and saved us a ton of money preparing our own food and grilling instead of eating downtown. Lots of parties at the cabins and the pool. Would stay again with a large group. "

"Wonderful!"

"Our first vacation to Put-in-Bay was a lot of fun. Our family had four cabins, all very close to one another, in a great location. For the $$$ charged for a five day stay, our cabin could use some TLC, better window treatments, general updating overall. Not sure who is responsible for housekeeping, prior occupants or rental agency, but floor had not been mopped and glass kitchen table must have been cleaned with dirty rag, as it was streaked with grime. Not sure if bed covers had been washed, so did not use them. After two days of smelling something foul, we discovered a throw pillow from the couch in the washing machine full of vomit. Left by last occupants?? Was meant to be washed by rental agency housekeeping and forgot to turn washer on??? It was Gross!! We left the cabin far cleaner then we found it. It was the right thing to do. "

"very good rental experience"

"We rented the house for 10 girls to attend a bachelorette party. It was a great experience. The house was very clean and welcoming. The space was great for 10 girls. Sleeping accommodations were nice and we could all hang out comfortably in the living/dining areas. The two decks were really nice as well. This house location was also great because it was kinda secluded off on the cul-de-sac. Another plus, most of the taxis would turn around in this area so we could easily get a tax within 5-10 minutes. I would definitely recommend staying in house #97!"

"Meh"

"Excellent customer service! We had an amazing time!
Unfortunately, it was too expensive to do as an anytime stay but I was able to splurge for the Bachelorette Party this one time!"

"Family and friends (all over 21) spent fourth of July weekend at Put In Bay to support our son's band, The Burning River Ramblers, that played at Hooligans Friday and Saturday night. We were very pleased with the cabin. Especially the nice accommodating layout and the 2 separate bathrooms. "

"The cabin was located in a cul-de-sac, which was perfect due to no thru traffic. We also did not have any neighbors behind us so the location was perfect! The home was clean for the most part, except for a few dead May Flies that were still plastered to the walls, windows and the skylight (inside the cabin). There was plenty of room and we had 9 ladies staying! The bathrooms were decent size and all of the appliances worked well. The only thing that we found they did not have in the kitchen was baking necessities (mixing bowls and cooking sheets) which would have been helpful since we did bake and cook most of our meals. Overall, we thoroughly enjoyed our stay! Thanks Island Club! If we ever have a large group go up again, we will be staying with you!"

"This was a midweek extended Family vacation. House was great and would definitely stay here again."

"This is the 4th time we have stayed at the Island Club and the 2nd time at Villa 97. The Villa accommodated 3 couples very well. The deck on the back of the house is spacious and surrounded by trees for added privacy. The house was clean, with the exception of the Mayflies that enjoy Put In Bay a few weeks each year! I would recommend renting a golf cart to fully enjoy the island. If you rent it from Island Club it will be waiting for you upon your arrival. Overall a great place to stay that is very close to the main strip."

"This delightful unit worked very well for our extended family of 10. The tub is only for show, however, which we found very disappointing. In addition, the air conditioning unit froze up several times so we couldn't get below 79 for the majority of our stay."

"It was great!! The rental property was very clean inside not so much outside.

Peaceful and very private, will be sure to plan another trip."

"we loved it when we go back we would love to have that cabin again just were it sits and we enjoyed the peace and quiet and listen to nature."

"Stayed here with girlfriends for a girls getaway weekend. We love enjoying our morning coffee on the deck listening to the birds. Meeting and talking with neighbors is always fun too. Going into town is a quick fun ride on the Island club taxis (ask for Tony). Property management is always available with friendly assistance if you have any issues-which is a rare occurrence. Have a great time! We sure did!"

"We stayed at the Island Club for a bachelorette party weekend. The cabin was perfect for our group and had everything we needed. We loved that the island club had its own taxi, Tony was always there to get us as soon as we called. We had a great time and are already thinking about coming back this summer."

"This is my 2nd time staying in this home at Island Club. You really cannot find anything even comparable to this quality for the price. The home is in great shape, and is very true to the pictures on the website. The amenities go above and beyond our expectations, including the gas grill, and the kitchen is stocked with dishes, pots, pans, utensils. If there's something you need that's not already stocked, the staff brings it promptly. The property and pool is very well-maintained and there's a real feel of "community", but the homes are still spaced sufficiently apart for privacy. I cannot express enough how exceptional the customer service is...Jerry, Dottie, Mitko, and the rest of the staff really are exceptional. I recommend Island Club to everyone I know that visits PIB!!"

"Great time - Gary (Gerry) with Island Club was great. He offered me a great rate and provided a very nice, clean and comfortable rental."

"The stay was very pleasant. The house was very clean and it was close to town. I would definitely stay again."

"I had a great experience the cabins we rented were clean and overall well kept.
The staff that we spoke with when renting were more than willing to work with us on rates due to the fact that our wedding party and guests were renting a large number of the cabins. The only thing I didn't really like was the check in process. You never really saw or spoke face to face with a person. I was given a code for the door and that is what let you in the cabin. I like a little more personal touch. But with that said it would not keep me from going back again."

"Had a great family vacation!! It was our first time on the island, and everyone was so nice and helpful! The manager was super helpful and the house was perfect. Will definitely be back to #97"

"The air conditioning was not working properly, very loud. The management co sent a repair person right away. He advised that the whole unit probably needs to be replaced. It did work, but was so loud, the baby with us work up throughout the night as it turned on."